HOME | INTRO | STAFF | SERVICES | ANNIVERSARY | RESEARCH
PUBLICATIONS | POSITIONS | LINKS | CAR IN THE NEWS | STUDENT RESOURCES | CONTACT

First Families in the Valley of Virginia:
Archaeology at the Parnassus Farm Site
(44AU634)
(dowload complete technical report)

Supported by:
Virginia Department of Transportation


Since the 1970s, thousands of archaeological projects have been conducted across the United States due to historic preservation legislation. The Virginia Department of Transportation (VDOT) accordingly accounts for historic properties in the course of its activities, and the study of the Parnassus Site (44AU634) for the Route 42 improvements project is a good example of VDOT's commitment to them. Studies like this one typically begin with a survey, or search, for archaeological sites where road projects are planned, and may be followed by a testing or evaluation phase at potentially significant sites. The final phase, if necessary, is a large-scale excavation, exemplified here at the Parnassus Site (44AU634), where the William and Mary Center for Archaeological Research performed such a study in 1999. This type of final, intensive study is designed to recover the important information that is present on a site.

View across the Parnassus Site Exposed outline of the lower structure foundation Exposed outline of the upper structure foundation

Click on the images above to view full size.

What Historical Documents Tell Us About the Site

The first written record of the land containing the Parnassus Site is a 1748 deed. A blacksmith named William King obtained a 400-acre tract along Moffett's Branch from the colonial government but resold it only a few years later, presumably for a quick profit. By 1751 John Nicholl had bought the 400 acres and was cultivating a mix of grain crops and raising livestock. After the elder John Nicholl died in 1774, his wife and children remained on the property as farmers. A 1755 inventory of assets accompanying Nicholl's will included hemp, hay, wheat, oats, barley, rye, and flax.

The family also owned 28 head of cattle, 11 hogs, 22 sheep, and nine horses. In the 1780s the farm passed through the ownership of Andrew Nicholl of Greenbrier County and later James Rankin, who owned some slaves.

Just before the Revolutionary War, Germans from Pennsylvania and the northern part of the Shenandoah valley began settling in Augusta County. In 1790, Adam Rusmeisel bought 150 acres that contained the Parnassus Site from the Nicholl heirs. He and his family farmed the land for the next 40 years. In the local German landholding tradition, several generations of Rusmeisels may have resided in separate households on the property simultaneously. One of the Rusmeisel dwellings is the first structure documented in the same location as the Parnassus Site. An 1831 turnpike survey map by Claudius Crozet shows the name "Rusmeisel's" next to a structure along the surveyed route. The Warm Springs-Harrisonburg Turnpike was the predecessor of the current Route 42 located next to the site.

Decorated bone handle of fork
from earlier structure [2.75 inches long].

Thomas Holt bought Christian Rusmeisel's 205-acre property in 1834 and steadily prospered during his fourteen years of ownership. Improvements (indicating structures) on the property increased in value from $150 to $1,000. Perhaps the original Rusmeisel dwelling was enlarged as part of these improvements. At the same time the surrounding community was growing, and a meeting house built in 1834 for religious and civic activities formed the core of the new village of Parnassus.

A Staunton merchant bought the Holts' farm in 1848 but waited four years before moving onto the land. William Kyle's ownership of the property raises some intriguing questions. The tax assessment of 1851-1852 shows a dramatic drop of $300 that may mark demolition of the dwelling. In 1853, Kyle conveyed the farm in trust to Benjamin Points for the use of his wife Felicia, sold his mercantile business, and built a substantial house worth $975 to as much as $2,000. Conveying the farm in trust at the same time as Kyle's mercantile interests were failing aroused the suspicions of his creditors. David Baylor's suit against Kyle resulted in an auction of the Kyle farm in the middle of the Civil War in 1863.

Both sides of a U.S. 3 cent coin (1853) found in the later structure at the site, which burned in the 1880's. Issued from 1851 to 1873, these are the smallest of American silver coins [0.6 inches in diameter].

By 1864 Union troops could have marched along the turnpike only a stone's throw from the Parnassus Site on their way to large encampments at nearby Staunton. The tax records do not indicate any major damage during the war, but rather steady assessments around $1,500. 

William McFall's ownership of the property from 1864 to 1879 parallels the sharp decline in agriculture after the Civil War. Although nearby towns such as Staunton and Waynesboro recovered quickly, surrounding agricultural communities struggled through this period. McFall first sold 125 acres to J. A. Hamrick in 1870. The following year McFall may have sold a quarter acre containing the main dwelling to Frank Harlow. An 1885 county atlas shows the label "Frank Harlow" next to a structure that appears to be on the Parnassus Site. Just west of the house is "Frank Harlow's Saddle Shop." McFall sold the remaining 128 acres of his original farm to J. A. Hamrick in 1879 and went bankrupt about the same time.

Historical documents concerning the Parnassus Site become more sketchy at this point. Although the 1885 county map clearly shows Frank Harlow's name on the property, he is curiously absent from the deed and tax books examined so far. Archaeological evidence points to a devastating fire in the house that William Kyle built.

The McFall farm was reunited when James Buckley bought 36 acres from the Harlow family in 1905, after buying the Hamrick property in 1902. The property was passed through the Hevener and Peterson families from 1909 to 1921. Since then the two tracts have been owned by three generations of the Fairburn family.

What Archaeology Tells Us about the Site

Archaeology findings at this site offered an unprecedented view of early historic settlement in the southern part of the Shenandoah Valley thanks to three factors. First of all, there was a rich historical record from documents that gave dates and names to go with what is in the ground. Second, remains of this farm were very well preserved beneath the ground, including not only traces of buildings but thousands of utilitarian and personal household items. And, third, the below-ground evidence represented different periods of occupation, which allowed us to examine changes in farm life over a long span of time.

The major features of the site were remains of at least two buildings, some scattered trash-filled pits, fence lines, and a well. Together, these represent the core of the historic farm site. It is not certain whether one of the buildings was built much earlier than the other, but it is clear that the lower building was abandoned first. Artifacts found in the cellar of this structure indicate that it ceased to be used by about 1830. We were able to tell this from the styles of the objects that were left there, such as pieces of ceramic bowls and plates, and glassware. More than likely, this building and the artifacts with it are associated with the first occupations of the site, or that of the Rusmeisel and Holt families. Historical records indicate that a later abandonment may have occurred.

The larger, upper building was not abandoned until the 1880s. Records indicate that the newer structure was built by William Kyle in the 1850s, perhaps to replace the older Rusmeisel-Holt dwelling. The excavation revealed that this building burned. Artifacts and other evidence in the cellar do suggest that it was a catastrophic fire, possibly occurring when Frank Harlow lived there. Many household items like large ceramic storage crocks remained upright and intact on the cellar floor. With them, too, were the remains of barrels, piles of walnuts, animal bone, and fabric. Apparently, the fire swept through the building so quickly that it was impossible to remove the contents. The effect for archaeologists was something like a small-scale Pompeii, where everyday things were discovered in the cellar's ashy deposit just as they were left at the time of the fire over a hundred years ago.

Ceramic crocks and barrel remain preserved on the cellar floor
of the upper structure, which burned in the 1880's.

After the excavation was completed, another stage of archaeology began in the laboratory. All of the artifacts were carefully analyzed along with the field results to prepare a final interpretation. One especially interesting aspect of the study was chemical analysis of locally made pottery to better understand the unique production and marketing system of Valley potters that once flourished in the area. Overall results were put in regional context to provide important details on local economic history. Please click this sentence to download the final report of the investigations.

TIME LINE

1748 Blacksmith William King obtains patent for 400 acres that includes Parnassus Site.
1751 King leases, then deeds the property to John Nicholl, a "middling farmer."
1760 Nicholl begins leasing 250 acres to his son John, Jr., for £5 per year.
1774 Elder John Nicholl's will divides property between widow Barbara and four sons.
1780 Barbara Nicholl and two of her sons convey 150-acre tract containing Parnassus Site to Andrew Nicholl of Greenbrier County.
1783 Andrew Nicholl sells the property, including "all houses, buildings, etc.," to James Rankin for £300.
1790 Rankin sells the 150-acre tract to Adam Rusmeisel for £130. Rusmeisel probably builds a dwelling at Parnassus Site.
1809 Adam Rusmeisel and wife Rachel sell the farm to their son Christian for £260.
1809-1832 Christian Rusmeisel adds 34 acres to the farm. 
1831 Rusmeisel dwelling appears on Claudius Crozet's survey map for the Warm Springs-Harrisonburg Turnpike.  House is located within boundary of Parnassus Site.
1834 Christian Rusmeisel sells the farm, now 205 acres, to Thomas Holt. Construction of meeting house for religious and community functions marks beginning of village of Parnassus.
1834-1848 Thomas Holt improves property: tax assessments on buildings increase steadily, from $150 to $1,000.
1848 Holt and wife Minerva sell 205-acre farm to merchant William Kyle but probably continue to live there until 1850.
1851-1852 Sudden drop of $300 in the tax assessment may indicate demolition of dwelling(?) structure. Tenants are likely living on the property.
1853 William Kyle conveys 205-acre farm in trust to Benjamin Points for the use of his wife Felicia.
1853-1855 Kyle sells his mercantile business, moves to farm, and builds new dwelling worth $975 to as much as $2,000. Suit by David Baylor suggests Kyle made Benjamin Points trustee to protect the farm from creditors.
1863 Due to Baylor's suit, Kyle farm is sold at auction to James Trotter; Archibald Trotter later becomes co-owner. Trotters resell property to James Crawford and F. M. Young.
1864 Crawford and Young sell 205-acre farm plus 52 acres to William and Isaiah McFall.
1864-1879 Steady decline in William McFall's property and eventual bankruptcy. Isaiah McFall disappears from records after initial purchase of property.
1864-1865 Union troops may have moved along the adjacent turnpike, but tax assessments indicate no destruction of property.
1870  William McFall sells 125 acres to J. A. Hamrick.
1871 Further 0.25-acre drop in McFall land assessment. McFall possibly sells 0.25 acre that includes dwelling to Frank Harlow. Harlow's name is printed next to a house and saddle shop on 1885 county atlas map, but few county records found refer to Harlow ownership.
1879 J. A. Hamrick buys McFall's remaining 128 acres.
1884 Hamrick makes $500 of improvements to property.
1902 Hamrick sells remaining 88 acres of McFall farm to James Buckley.
1905 James Buckley acquires 36 acres from Harlow family, which includes Parnassus Site.
1909 Buckley sells his 88- and 36-acre tracts to J. W. Hevener, who conveys them to G. W. Hevener a few days later.
1916 Upon his death, G. W. Hevener's property passes to granddaughter, Elizabeth Peterson, who already owns 47-acre tract containing Harlow house and Parnassus Site.
1921 Elizabeth and her husband, W. B. Peterson, sell 124-acre Hevener tract and 47-acre Harlow tract to J. W. Fairburn.
1945 J. Wayne Fairburn inherits the tracts from his father, J. W. Fairburn.
1993 John Wayne Fairburn and sister Cindy Fairburn Lundy inherit the tracts from their father, J. Wayne Fairburn.
1994 Fairburn siblings execute deed of partition dividing their father's property.

Suggested Readings

Deetz, James
1977 In Small Things Forgotten: The Archaeology of Early American Life . Anchor Press/Doubleday, Garden City, New York.

HOME | INTRO | STAFF | SERVICES | ANNIVERSARY | RESEARCH
PUBLICATIONS | POSITIONS | LINKS | CAR IN THE NEWS | STUDENT RESOURCES | CONTACT